There is a lot of talk about building low-cost housing. It is just talk.
So how can empty talk be turned into reality? It would take three things:
1. Big changes to municipal zoning bylaws & neighbourhood infrastructures.
2. The building of basic low-cost housing.
3. Everyone understanding that these buildings are designed to be affordable.
These condos, and small purpose-built rental buildings, can't be taller
than five floors. The bottom floor can—and probably should—contain
retail and commercial units. (Although in China, walk-ups go as high as
seven-stories as buyers will climb the extra stairs in exchange for
lower monthly maintenance fees.)
These low-rise condo buildings should be be allowed downtown on
residential streets and along major streets in the suburbs. It is
critical that they have 24-hour bus or streetcar service. For this
model to thrive, the municipalities must insure that these
neighbourhoods are zoned for local retail shopping and have adequate
schools, parks, libraries and community centres.
The retail and commercial zoning by-laws must be "start-up business"
friendly. All the little independent mom and pop shops that the large
mixed-condo developments and the trendy streets don't want need these
buildings to be able to get established and then flourish.
Building applications should be fast-tracked through the approval
stages and they need sufficient political support to insure that these
affordable housing projects don't get rejected because of NIMBY
Walkups are not new
A boom in the construction of walk-up rental apartment buildings
occurred in Toronto from the late 1910s through the 1920s. A second
generation of small walk-up apartment buildings were built after World
War Two. They are often overlooked but they still line many streets in
Apartment house, 610-614 Ontario St, elevation, November 1912
Apartments, 147-151 Palmerston Ave, elevation, October 8, 1912
Row of small walk-up apartment buildings, Wilson Avenue, North York
A walk-up on Wilson Avenue. Note the staircase in the entrance way.
We stopped building walk-ups when condominiums become more profitable to build.
What makes walk-ups different?
A modern six-storey walk-up condo in northeast China.
To make good affordable housing, instead of making apartments smaller
and smaller, it is important that we build large two and three-bedroom
units. The savings come from building four to five storey apartment
buildings and by stripping away the extras, not by making smaller and
There can't be any underground parking because it costs $25,000 or more
a unit to build an underground parking garage and it costs $500 a year
per parking unit for servicing, cleaning and maintenance. Underground
garages need lighting, exhaust fans, emergency exits, heated ramps and
When the building ages, it can cost millions to renovate an underground
parking garage so the Reserve Funds need to be built up years prior to
the work being done.
Instead of parking, these buildings have basements that contains
residential lockers, bicycle racks and common element service rooms.
Elevators are expensive to install, service, maintain and to refurbish.
Concrete staircases are cheap to build and need little ongoing
These condos will be a lot faster to build if there isn't any underground parking and elevators.
No central air conditioning
The residents can install after-market air conditioning units that sit on small concrete pads.
Balconies are expensive to install and very expensive to refurbish
20-30 years down the road when the concrete and railings detoriate.
Balconies are hard to insulate and they are a major source of water
No balconies means no satellite dishes, cigarette smokers, propane BBQs or the storage of flammables on balconies.
No central hot water
The units will have their own electric hot water tank installed in the
bathroom. The units are supplied only with cold water. You turn on the
tank 20 minutes before you want a shower and turn it off when your
shower is over. The hot water remaining in the tank will be used later
to wash the dishes.
The savings is in not having an expensive "instant hot water" system
that requires two boilers and having hot water continously running
through the pipes 24 hours a day.
There will be no swimming pools, hot tubs, party rooms, theatres,
basketball courts or guest suites. Forget having a fancy two-storey
Want a fitness centre? Sure thing; Hauling your beer, cat litter and
groceries up those stairs is all the excercise you'll need.
Each unit will have separate metering for electricity, water and
natural gas. You pay for your own telephone and entertainment services.
A well designed ground-floor unit.
The units can run from plain-Jane ho-hum units to eye-popping
custom-built beauties. It depends on the owner's tastes and budget.
Over time, renovations keep the units fresh and desirable.
At night this Korean-style tea room doubles up as a guest bedroom, or a third bedroom.
Inexpensive condos buildings can contain luxury units. Bare-bone models
could create a local industry that designs, builds and installs custom
condo interiors for the owners when their finances allow it.
Will they sell?
It will take a while for North Americans to appreciate the value here
but once a few are built, I am sure new developments will be very
chapter previous next