The beat goes on
“The beat goes on, the beat goes on
Drums keep pounding a rhythm to the brain”
—Sonny & Cher

Auditing scandals continue as routinely as the changing seasons.

Rub of the Green
Private Eye #1424
05 Aug 2016

The parliamentary investigation into the demise of BHS could be  just the start of the troubles for PwC, the realtor's auditor.

As Eye 1422 pointed out, the firm approved BHS's accounts just five days before the ill-fated takeover by Dominic Chappell's company in March last year, without raising any question about whether it was a going concern. Since it wouldn't have taken much business acumen to be sceptical about the three-time bankrupt wide-boy, this looked reckless. As the Commons work and pensions select committee noted: "We were surprised that PwC did not more deeply question whether BHS was genuinely being sold as a going concern."

It also emerged in the inquiry that the nature of support being given by the green family's Taveta group was weakened dramatically two days before the accounts were signed off. A rigorous auditor might have been expected to investigate this a bit futher, given that there was no certainly over the sale at that point. A clean audit certificate was essential, and that is what BHS got—strangely (and conveniently) a couple of months earlier than it had for previous years' accounts.

Evidence submitted to the committee showed how important clean audit certificates were to Sir Philip Green. Some months before the sale, he was reported by the pension trustees to be refusing to answer "moral hazard" questions (ie how much he had taken out of the company) on the grounds that PwC's clean audits covered him. In return, PwC's northern office did very nicely out of the company, pocketing 335,000 in audit fees and 2.9 million for other work. And as the MPs observed, PwC had a "long-standing relationship with Sir Philip Green."

The Financial Reporting Council is now looking at PwC's work and "aims" to conclude its inquiry within two years.


Stricken Kiev
Private Eye #1449
Jul-Aug 2017

Ukraine's central bank last week banned the local arm of accountancy firm PwC from auditing the country's banks after it failed to spot risky loans and investments at the country's largest lender.

It said that the report issued by PricewaterhouseCoopers Audit LLC "failed to highlight the credit risk exposure faced by Privatbank, which led to the bank being declared insolvent and nationalised, with substantial recapitalisation costs borne by the state."

Replace Privatbank with say, Northern Rock, and this would pretty much describe what happened in the UK financial crisis. Similar could be said at RBS (audited by Deloitte) and HBOS (KPMG). A parliamentary committee did criticise PwC's work on the Rock, but here the Big Four accountancy firms are considered too few to fail and would never be denied their right to earn squillions glossing over unreliable numbers. Britain lags somewhere behind Ukraine in cleaning up the beancounters.

top  contents  appendix  previous  next