English not required for strata council meetings: Ministry of Housing
Richmond News
Graeme Wood
14 September 2016

Andreas Kargut is leading a class-action Human Rights Tribunal claim against his strata council, which he claims has discriminated against non-Mandarin speaking homeowners. Dec. 2015.

No amendments to B.C.’s Strata Property Act, to include English as the mandatory language of record in strata council meetings, appear to be in the works.

Following a spat over language between strata members in Richmond that has garnered international attention, the Richmond News posed the question—Is the Ministry of Housing working to amend the Strata Property Act to make English (and/or French) the mandatory language for strata council meetings? — to Richmond East MLA Linda Reid, who deferred to the Ministry Responsible for Housing, which oversees the legislation.

Reid had previously told the Richmond News in February she will be advocating for language requirements in the B.C. Strata Property Act —although, as Speaker of the House, she cannot table a motion in the Legislature herself.

The Ministry responded by stating it was only aware of one strata corporation where language has been raised as a concern.

“We examine issues related to strata legislation on an ongoing basis,” stated Ministry spokesperson Lindsay Byers, via email.

The Ministry did have a suggestion

The Ministry did have a suggestion, however, for residents of Wellington Court on Heather Street, who have squared off against one another, with one side claiming it’s OK for council members to speak Mandarin at meetings and the other side contending doing so is contrary to their human rights in a country where the official languages are English and French.

“We strongly encourage strata corporations to choose an inclusive approach to provide accessibility to all strata members,” stated Byers.

“One option would be to provide interpretation services to other languages; however, the technical requirements of strata legislation can be difficult to interpret accurately and should only be contemplated by a qualified official interpreter.”

According to Wellington Court resident Andreas Kargut, his strata council has chosen not to hire a qualified official interpreter. Last year, the council spoke Mandarin at the Annual General Meeting, leaving non-Mandarin speakers feeling excluded.

The matter sparked a B.C. Human Rights Tribunal complaint that now appears to be going to an official hearing, after an agreement to settle the dispute fell apart in August.

Byers added that the Province of B.C. has no official language requirements and Canada’s official languages only apply to federal government business and services.

Kargut and a group of six, including some who are ethnic Chinese, claim discrimination by their council.

Wellington Court resides in the City Centre planning area, where only 38.4 per cent of residents speak English at home whereas 51.7 per cent speak Chinese (16 per cent Mandarin), according to 2011 National Household Survey data.


top  contents  appendix  previous  next