Neighbours’ lives turned upside down by Airbnb and other ‘disruptors’
By Clay Lucas
25 July 2018
Defecating in the sauna. Breaking bottles in the apartment tower’s
swimming pool. Leaving running taps on so apartments flood. Vomiting in
This is just some of the behaviour Katherine Hughes has seen from short-stay guests in her A’Beckett Street apartment tower.
It’s the same block where, on Saturday, 19-year-old Laa Chol was killed on level 56. That apartment was booked via Airbnb.
But Booking.com, HomeAway and other “sharing economy” platforms are
used just as much to let units in the Eq Tower, where Ms Hughes and her
family have lived since it opened last year.
Airbnb distribution in Melbourne
On Saturday, Ms Hughes struggled to get a lift downstairs – all were stuck on level 56.
When she finally descended to the foyer, to take her son to weekend
sport, police filled the foyer, there to investigate Ms Chol's death (a
17-year-old has since been charged with murder).
The death shocked residents. The violence didn’t.
“Most residents will be able to tell you of a time when a party on
their floor got out of control and … they were too scared to confront
the partygoers,” says Ms Hughes, who is regularly kept awake by
parties. Last time she confronted youths at 3am, they abused her.
Each weekend the 70 per cent of permanent residents in the tower face
an onslaught of holidaymakers who Ms Hughes says “don’t care if you see
them vomiting or something like that”.
Since Saturday’s incident, The Age has spoken to dozens of residents
affected by a range of short-stay lettings in their block, their
street, their neighbourhood.
Since Airbnb began “disrupting” the hotel industry a decade ago, the home-sharing economy has escalated wildly.
In Melbourne, there are 20,400 homes listed on that site alone,
according to the InsideAirbnb website, which tracks the company (Airbnb
disputes the website's accuracy).
As Airbnb has boomed, scores of competing homesharing websites, and established travel sites, have joined the frenzy.
Some, like Port Melbourne host Gillian Butler are the very model of sharing economy success.
The ground floor of her three-storey building is used for a business.
The two floors above, which Ms Butler once rented to her children, are
now on Airbnb.
“I love it because I can call the shots,” says Ms Butler, who enjoys meeting people from all over the world.
Ms Butler is the sort of success story Airbnb and other sharing sites
use to promote a system used by 1.8 million guests in Melbourne last
year, one which Deloitte Access Economics says now contributes $413
million to Victoria's gross state product.
There is no stopping Airbnb and other companies now – in part because it is so popular with travellers.
But Eq Tower’s Ms Hughes says the idea companies such as Airbnb are
trying to maintain – “a sharing concept – rent out a bedroom if you
have a spare” – is increasingly a fiction.
“Now it’s a business designed to help people get cheap accommodation
and for investors to make more money,” says Ms Hughes, who argues “the
sharing economy” is slowly transforming into an economy where
neighbours such as herself are being asked to foot the bill for other
This is hardly news to the Victorian government – and yet it has done nothing.
Labor came to office promising to “improve the regulation of CBD
residential buildings, so property is protected from unruly ‘short
The government’s response to an inquiry analysing its proposed
short-stay bill found that “anecdotal evidence” indicated “some
apartment residents currently feel unsafe in their buildings”.
That anecdotal evidence is starting to turn into a flood of hard evidence.
In the wake of Laa Chol’s death, outraged residents contacted The Age
with remarkably similar tales of hell caused by short-term lettings.
Among them is Jack Clarke, who in 2008 moved into his Queens Road
apartment with housemate Peter Itchins. They had no problems with the
apartment upstairs until last year, when it was placed on Airbnb.
Now, he says, parties regularly rage upstairs into the early hours of
the night, suitcase wheels scrape across their ceilings, there is
regular loud singing and dragging of furniture above them.
Mr Clarke, a tax lawyer, has scrupulously documented his complaints,
which range from confronting a scared woman with a blood nose to
regular trips upstairs at 2am to demand the noise is kept down, to
encountering groups of up to 15 people staying in the three-bedroom
Mr Clarke has contacted Airbnb repeatedly; the company’s response is it
is powerless to act. (On Wednesday, an Airbnb spokesman told The Age it
was investigating the complaints again.)
The pair’s negotiation with the apartment’s owner, Mr Clarke says, has
resulted in everything from offers of cash bribes to a threat of an
apprehended violence order against them.
While Victoria has done nothing to regulate the short-stay industry,
governments elsewhere have cracked down on Airbnb and other platforms.
In Sydney, laws may soon be passed so that apartments can’t be let for
more than 180 nights a year and a vote of 75 per cent or more of owners
in a block can ban short-term lettings outright.
Japan is set to enforce tougher laws on apartment sharing, and protest
movements in cities including Venice, Berlin and San Francisco have
seen residents publicise how short-term lets are forcing out long-term
The Greens MP for Melbourne, Ellen Sandell, was elected in 2014 and has
regularly been contacted by residents affected by the rise of Airbnb
and other home-sharing sites.
She says, while Labor promised to tackle the issue since the last
election, they didn’t really want to do anything. "It’s taken a crisis
for Daniel Andrews to become interested”.
Consumer Affairs Minister Marlene Kairouz though says the laws the
government brought into parliament in 2016 would "help stamp out unruly
behaviour", and protect residents. She said the Greens and the state
Coalition were "playing politics" by not backing the laws.
It isn’t just apartments being affected by short-stay lettings. In
April, North Melbourne resident Eliana Tait saw how badly things can go
wrong when lettings aren’t properly policed.
That night partygoers at the two-bedroom townhouse next door – which
had been regularly booked out over previous weeks – pelted police with
objects and smashed up their cars.
While Airbnb has become a verb for the online short-stay industry, the
proliferation of other sites has made it harder for neighbours to
resolve their problems.
'They're absolute pigs'
Yarra Valley resident Maddy, who asks that her surname not be used,
says her short-stay nightmare began in 2016 when the house next door
was sold to investors.
“The first weekend they rented it out, we were just like ‘Holy moly!’.
Thirty people turned up, there were people everywhere sleeping in cars."
Now, Maddy dreads weekends, when the house is leased for $300 a night.
Listed on Airbnb, Booking.com, Homeaway, HomeToGo, Trivago, TripAdvisor
and Expedia, among others, Maddy is never clear which platform to
Usually the house is rented by wedding parties, with groomsmen arriving
on a Friday. “They party all night and they are absolute pigs,” says
Maddy, who then watches as their guests arrive on Saturday. “The party
starts again on Saturday night once the wedding is over.”
When Maddy has complained to the police, if they come at all, it’s
obvious who's called them. “Then you've got 20 drunken people in there,
and you feel in danger, so I don't do that.”
Maddy has also complained to the Yarra Ranges Council, but they say they are powerless to act.
Linda Wimetal has learnt the hard way how powerless councils are to
take meaningful action against owners of short-stay lettings who do the
Her home in Rye is next door to a large family home that was once rented to a family.
Now, “it’s like having them partying in my bedroom at night it’s so loud,” she says, describing this past summer as “from hell”.
Her local council, Mornington Peninsula, has tried valiantly to help
her and hundreds of others affected by the peninsula’s 1185 short-stay
Officers from the council installed noise-monitoring equipment, got
evidence it breached the Environment Protection Act and served notices
on the owner.
It solved the problem for a while, but 18 months later the owner re-listed the property on Airbnb.
“We were back to square one,” says Ms Wimetal, who says only one thing will help her: stronger laws.